• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar

CHEM Trust

Protecting humans and wildlife from harmful chemicals

  • Home
    • Our policy site
    • Advice for consumers
  • About us
    • About CHEM Trust
    • CHEM Trust Europe
    • Our team
    • Trustees of CT UK
    • Our funders
    • Contact
    • Jobs
    • Privacy Policy
  • Our work
    • Our work – UK, EU and global
    • Newsletters
    • Publications
    • Talks & comment
    • EU policy submissions
    • UK policy submissions
  • Problem chemicals
    • Hormone Disrupting Chemicals FAQ
    • Bisphenols
    • Phthalates
    • PFAS
    • Pharmaceutical pollution
    • Chemicals and plastics
  • Chemical impacts
    • Health impacts
    • Wildlife impacts
  • Chemicals policy
    • EU-REACH
    • UK policy
    • Chemicals and the Circular Economy
    • Food contact materials
    • Persistent Organic Pollutants (POPs)
    • Chemical mixtures
    • Toxic-free toys
    • Universal PFAS Restriction
  • Take Action

Review of UK REACH: three years on

February 23, 2024 By Chloe Alexander

Review of UK REACH: three years on

Last week, the UK chemicals regulator (the Health & Safety Executive) published the UK REACH work programme for 2023-4 with just a few weeks left to run of the period it covers.

It marks over 3 years since the UK left the EU chemicals management system (EU REACH) and established UK REACH as an independent, standalone system for regulating chemicals.

While the UK’s regulation of chemicals stands still, the EU continues to make progress (albeit slowly) in banning harmful chemicals and controlling pollution at source. The UK system is also being eroded by a weakening of its chemical safety rules and processes. This may result not only in the dumping of products that no longer meet higher EU standards on the UK market, but also the potential for the UK to manufacture chemicals and products containing chemicals that the EU has restricted for being too harmful. An accompanying briefing sets out the information below in more detail.

The UK continues to fall behind EU protections.

While the EU continues to progress in improving its chemicals regulatory system and controlling harmful chemicals – despite some recent setbacks – the UK is moving more slowly and taking a less protective approach.

Examples include:

  1. The decision by the UK Government only to match new EU classifications for better identifying known and suspected endocrine disrupting chemicals (EDCs) if they are adopted globally, which could take many years. By comparison, the EU plans to phase out all substances identified as EDCs from toys, paving the way for better protection of children, who are particularly vulnerable to adverse impacts from EDCs.
  2. The UK has added no new substances to its authorisation list, compared to five added to the EU’s list, including Tetraethyllead in aviation fuel. Companies cannot use or manufacture any substance on the list unless given ‘authorisation’ by the regulatory agency. Analysis suggests that applications to use substances on the list are more likely to succeed in the UK, such as for chromium trioxide, a carcinogenic chemical linked to increased risk of lung and throat cancer.
  3. Thirdly, the UK has yet to adopt a single new ban or restriction on a harmful substance, compared to 8 new restrictions on harmful substances adopted in the EU. So far, it has initiated two restrictions (on harmful substances in tattoo ink and lead in ammunition), compared to 17 initiated by the EU. It is positive that the UK’s proposed restriction on harmful substances used in tattoo ink restricts the vast majority of substances in the scope of the EU’s, but it is still weaker than the EU’s.
  • The gap with the EU is set to become a chasm over the coming years if the EU’s Restrictions Roadmap is fully implemented. The roadmap accelerates EU restrictions by targeting entire groups of widely used chemicals of concern, such as bisphenols and brominated flame retardants. If fully implemented, it would lead to an estimated 5-7,000 chemicals being banned by 2030.
  • In its work programme, the regulator, the Health & Safety Executive (HSE), deprioritised 12 harmful substances on which the EU has either adopted or initiated a restriction. This list includes the use of lead in PVC and a restriction on PAHs used in synthetic football pitches and playgrounds that are linked to increased cancer risk, both of which have been adopted by the EU. The reasons it gives show the regulator is setting a higher bar for evidence of harm than the EU before taking action.
  1. It is striking how few of the actions identified for regulatory priorities in 2022-3 have been delivered, almost two years later. This delays regulatory action to prevent harm to our health and environment from prolonged exposure to harmful chemicals.

 Examples: from the five substances identified as regulatory priorities for 2022-3, compared to action at EU level:

  • The Regulatory Management Options Analysis (RMOA) on PFAS promised for 2022-3 has been published, but restriction(s) – which are subject to legislative deadlines by which the regulator must submit its proposals – have not yet been initiated. This is very concerning as these chemicals are highly persistent, and every year of inaction leads to increased concentrations in our environment. Our European neighbours are already benefitting from better regulation on PFAS with new statutory standards on drinking water and new food standards, as well as a ban already in force and another expected to be adopted very soon on sub-sets of PFAS. The EU has also published its proposal for a universal restriction of PFAS as a class.
  • An external organisation has only recently been commissioned to undertake the evidence review that was promised for 2022-3 of pollution from microplastics that are deliberately added to products. There is no indication whether the Government supports matching a wide-ranging EU restriction on intentionally added microplastics, which has been in force since October 2023.
  • While the UK records globally significant exposure rates to flame retardants, the review to ‘feed into wider chemicals policy’ promised for 2022-3 has not yet been published. By comparison, the EU Restrictions Roadmap proposes a restriction on brominated flame retardants as a group, and eight flame retardants have been added to its list of Substances of Very High Concern, while no substances of any kind have been added to the equivalent UK list.

The reasons for these delays include the lack of staff to consider risk management of harmful chemicals at the same scale and pace as the EU, as well as a lack of transparency in how decisions are made and significant pushes in the system against new regulation.

Watering down of UK chemical safety rules

At the same time as falling behind EU standards, in some areas the UK has been going backwards:

  • Weakening of ‘no data, no market’ principle: Last year, the Government reduced the chemical safety information companies will be required to provide on substances they place on the UK market, because of the cost of accessing this data registered at EU level. This will make it more difficult for the regulator to check that industry understands the risks of the chemicals they use and to make risk management decisions about them.
  • Substances of Very High Concern (SVHC) Over the last three years, the EU has added 31 substances to its SVHC list, while no substance has been added to the UK’s list or is expected to be added in this Parliament. The list has been very effective at the EU level in encouraging innovation in safer alternatives, but in the UK has been left to ‘wither on the vine’.

Next steps

We need to strengthen UK REACH, by ensuring it meets or exceeds EU chemical laws and standards. A regulatory system based on the one in Switzerland, which defaults to aligning with EU chemical safety laws, would provide a long-term, cost-effective and sustainable approach to regulating chemicals. It would also provide a way of minimising costs to industry while upholding high standards.

Chloe Alexander, Senior Campaigner, CHEM Trust, said:

“Three years on from establishing a regulatory system independent of the EU’s, it’s striking how little progress has been made in banning harmful substances and controlling pollution at source.

“The latest UK REACH work programme offers far fewer and weaker protections from hazardous chemicals than its EU equivalent, and at an even slower pace. All of its priorities involve additional preparatory work gathering evidence and analysing regulatory options, which hinder the regulator’s ability to take swift action. This is resulting in a second-rate system for regulating chemicals and less protection for people and nature in the UK from harmful chemicals than our European neighbours.  

Further information:

UK REACH Work Programme 2023-24, including:

  • Rationale for prioritising substances in the UK REACH work programme: 2023 to 2024
  • UK REACH activities 2022-3

CHEM Trust divergence table on the differences between UK and EU regulatory bans or controls on harmful substances

CHEM Trust briefing – Review of UK REACH: 3 years on

Coverage:

George Monbiot, Britain is becoming a toxic chemical dumping ground – yet another benefit of Brexit The Guardian, March 2024

Share this:

  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email

Primary Sidebar

Subscribe to Toxic-Free for EU

Subscribe to Toxic-Free for EU, a weekly briefing on EU politics and chemicals regulatory affairs.

Subscribe here

Subscribe to our blog

Get an email when we publish a new blog post

Follow us

  • Bluesky
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn

Bluesky

Copyright CHEM Trust · Reg Charity No. 1118182 · Disclaimer · Login

Want to keep up-to-date with our work?

Subscribe to the CHEM Trust newsletter.

Subscribe here